How would you feel about a younger River?

How would you feel about having a younger River Song?

I mean I wouldnt mind it but, they would have to find a suitable replacement. Alex Kingston's shows are very hard to fill.

if you wanted a younger River Song who would you like to fill the role?

I wouldnt mind it either as long as they dont go down the Rose and The Doctor route.
I dont know who could play Alex Kingston.

I wouldnt like it.
It would just feel icky.

That would be really weird but I am sure it is doable if they base the actress on how she would of looked in the older series when she was younger then.
But that's just me being too anal I think.
Also but on the flip side of things she is a time lord so the re incarnation of every time lord always looks different anyways.

SonicScrewdriver wrote:That would be really weird but I am sure it is doable if they base the actress on how she would of looked in the older series when she was younger then.
But that's just me being too anal I think.
Also but on the flip side of things she is a time lord so the re incarnation of every time lord always looks different anyways.

I think the problem is as of yet there is no proof that she can regenerate. The Little Girl and River could be two different people. I dont fully believe that myself but you have to consider it. We dont know how many female timelords Moffat has running about Whoniverse.

Rostaria wrote:
I think the problem is as of yet there is no proof that she can regenerate. The Little Girl and River could be two different people. I dont fully believe that myself but you have to consider it. We dont know how many female timelords Moffat has running about Whoniverse.

Oh seriously you cant say there is more Time Lords running around out there. I was under the impression that Moffat didnt want the Time Lords returning.

I agree with this point I think there is only two others, the doctors daughter(clone) if anyone remembers from the previous series with David Tennant in and the little girl.

SonicScrewdriver wrote:I agree with this point I think there is only two others, the doctors daughter(clone) if anyone remembers from the previous series with David Tennant in and the little girl.

I am off the mind that the Little Girl and River are the same people.

I suppose its possible as if you think how Amelie conceived and where she was at the time.

SonicScrewdriver wrote:I suppose its possible as if you think how Amelie conceived and where she was at the time.

Do you mean Melody?

Could be, I am just making a comparison really and saying that anything is possible in the world of Doctor Who.

SonicScrewdriver wrote:Could be, I am just making a comparison really and saying that anything is possible in the world of Doctor Who.

Amelia was concieved we can only presume naturally. In a normal bed in a normal house. Melody was concieved in a TARDIS. There are a world apart.

Ah sorry I didn't word my post properly, I meant the one conceived in the TARDIS.
I got confused, time is confusing.XD><

SonicScrewdriver wrote:Ah sorry I didn't word my post properly, I meant the one conceived in the TARDIS.
I got confused, time is confusing.XD><

That is Melody/River.

Yeah that's what i thought all along excuse my lack in wording and sense, its getting late.

SonicScrewdriver wrote:Yeah that's what i thought all along excuse my lack in wording and sense, its getting late.

LOL go to bed then!

I would be okay with it. As long as they did it well.